FAQ/Help |
Calendar |
Search |
Veteran Member
Member Since Mar 2019
Location: USA
Posts: 540
5 55 hugs
given |
#41
I was googling what's out there publicly about the podcast right now and there are plenty of hits but they aren't very meaningful articles, basically just describing and advertising it mostly. I found a reply on Joe Nocera's Twitter saying "And STILL (apparently) no comment from @nyulangone, despite numerous red flags in the form of a lengthy OPMC investigation and Dr Herschkopf's decision to leave the APA's local and state chapters." But, considering the short time since the podcast has come out, I think it receives quite a lot of publicity. I do believe more serious interrogations take time.
I am very interested in this now, in part because I have colleagues in the Psychiatry area at NYU. Might just ask around myself (but will finish listening to the series first). |
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, missbella
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#42
Quote:
Yes, NYC is an auspicious institution to have a kook doctor on its roster. I know they can't cut him loose without due process, but this has to have caused buzz. The patient, Marty and witnesses have plenty of evidence. Worse is how the New York Office of Professional Medical Conduct seems to have file drawered the complaint. |
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, Xynesthesia2
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Mar 2019
Location: USA
Posts: 540
5 55 hugs
given |
#43
Yes the mental health profession in NYC has many elements akin to a mafia network. It is very had to remain free of it if you want to work maintaining some sort of academic association, can be easier completely self-employed and staying away from all that but then many people feel isolated and dissatisfied. Not going into it but this issue has been a big part of some things I struggle with myself and still haven't made a clear decision, let alone action. Of course it is much more complicated than just thriving or failing as an academic or clinician as the field is intertwined, in many ways, with hardcore money and politics. I can easily imagine why it took so long for Marty to break free, I am certain it is not just emotional factors but the involvement of serious business that he probably could not cut off and resolve without some serious losses as well. Having made those early decisions and investments must have brought consequences for a long time.
My first T actually made that decision to cut ties with most of the psych-related institutions and investors quite early in his career and do everything solo. In that case, I think it just turned him into a greater evil and more dangerous practitioner because there is no one to control him even slightly, except the licensing board I guess, but he seems to be very good at getting rid of accusations of all kinds, amazing good in fact (I know because I tried in smaller ways as well). But going solo did not abolish his enormous need for attention, coupled with a failure of actually producing work good enough to be recognized and appreciated by the academic community (he is just inherently sloppy and also not very smart, I think). So he targets a certain population of clients that are much less likely to scrutinize him. I think he reacted to the conflicts with me so extremely because I do not fall in that population and did not buy his shady maneuvers and manipulations but, instead, told him many things that must have pierced into some of his biggest insecurities. He really produced emotional reactions in response that I had never seen from anyone, very extreme. But I could not do much to formally interrogate him and I also just did not have the desire to engage in such a crap and make life worse for myself. He actually pretty much damaged his own reputation by himself with all the *** he does on the internet. That also shows he is obsessed with attention seeking but not very smart. I expect Ike to be much smarter, given the scale of manipulations he has managed to execute and maintain. |
Reply With Quote |
missbella
|
koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jul 2017
Location: Neverland
Posts: 1,805
6 4,957 hugs
given |
#44
I cant believe how consequence-free this all has been for the pyschiatrist so far. He creates his own reality, then lives in it to his own serious advantage. he is 70 now, so unless he goes to actual jail, the worst that will happen is he will be embarrassed. I doubt he will feel that way though.
__________________ Living things don’t all require/ light in the same degree. Louise Gluck |
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, missbella, Quietmind 2, Xynesthesia2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#45
Quote:
I can easily see a practitioner following his notions after a while. Another doctor won’t see the patient with an incorrectly-set broken leg. I also can’t say definitively I’d break from a cult faster than Marty. But I’ve always had people around for feedback and vigilance imparted from an attorney father. But the doctor controlled more than Marty— he intimidated everyone in Marty’s business into silence. Then too, the doctor’s family apparently joined the exploitation. I await NYU and NY’s OPMC responses. I’d wager the doctor continues in his rescuer fantasy as other censured clinicians have done before. |
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2, SalingerEsme, Xynesthesia2
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Mar 2019
Location: USA
Posts: 540
5 55 hugs
given |
#46
Yes definitely on an elite level - that is why it is so hard to scrutinize people like him. Others who have the power to seriously interfere are likely to be embedded in the culture themselves, if not in his empire, then in their own ways.
I really doubt that the psychiatrist would be fazed too much, even if he was investigated via NYU or other professional organizations. A criminal case, of course, may be different, but I imagine he is also well-connected in those domains if he has been able to get away with all this for decades. And, as said above, he is pretty much retirement age now and I don't think even losing his business or a good amount of money would do too much harm to his lifestyle at this point. Clearly he has never been one to worry much about his morals. I have seen a few high profile academics and clinicians fired by their organizations for ethical misconduct (sometimes with criminal elements usually obscured), they may be on some level in the news for a little while but then the case disappears and they typically start doing something else instead of fighting much. I do often wonder what might be going on in the psyche of these kinds of people... how they can live with what to do. I know I would not be able to do it, no matter what sorts of benefits, I would probably kill myself out of guilt and cognitive dissonance. Probably they do not suffer too much dissonance internally - sort of a psychopathic phenotype. |
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, missbella, Quietmind 2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#47
Quote:
I agree with you. I guess he convinced himself, as many practitioners do, that his acting outside of convention was best for his patient. (He also had the alibi he transitioned Marty from patient to business client.) Paradoxically, this guy has extensive writings on religion and ethical issues. That would have fooled me for a while as I'm sure it fooled others. I'm sure I'd hide if I were subject to that level of public censure. But he continues. His wife is visible online too, pretty as you please. |
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2, Xynesthesia2
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Mar 2019
Location: USA
Posts: 540
5 55 hugs
given |
#48
Quote:
My first T was an example for those engaging in this kind of duality in smaller ways. I bought into it in the beginning for a few months (I had no experience with therapy then) but it became increasingly clear that he was absolutely not doing what he preached in his media, quite the opposite. He says all the right things about therapy but practices none or very little. That was one of the things I pointed out to him multiple times, one of those things that made him extremely angry and defensive. I said he wasn't very smart, but smart enough to make a whole career based on his natural tendencies and behaviors, turning his crappy acts into theories (mostly copying, he isn't creative enough to make his own) and advertising as therapy techniques. But he compromised his own image by not being able to control himself online and making it clear that those apparent "techniques" are just his effortless, natural behaviors. He also really lost it with me in the end and all the shite was out clear as day. Well, "out" in a small way, mostly between us and a bit on the web... but nothing big. I see now that he advertises quite desperately on/off on the web looking for clients and mentees (he also does supervision) - pretty sure he has had time finding work now. I think there is a factor of identification in clients who associate with these guys and I've figured it from my own experience. I was originally drawn to my T in a period when my own responsibility and morals were very shaky, I also manipulated my environment a lot to get away with my own compulsions (addiction in my case). It was very clear from other social associations I had developed during those years - basically hooking up with people who kinda reflected the worst of me. The T of course would explain that as some sort of parental transference but it was nothing like that for me, it was hating some things in him that I hated the most in my own behavior when it happened. But it did not last because my personality / morals are not truly like that, it was mostly the side effects of active addiction for a few years, never before and not currently. Very easy for me to imagine that Ike's clients struggle with forms of this thing. |
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#49
My timid, deferential self was particularly drawn to manic, hysterical personalities who ignored rules and barriers. I felt complemented by people who gave me structure and rules. It was a way of extending childhood.
Though the podcast relationship was extreme, I think it's easy for a therapist to gain detrimental dominance over a client. I hope this case begins some discussion. Last edited by missbella; Jun 12, 2019 at 06:56 PM.. |
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Oct 2011
Location: the sunny side of the street
Posts: 672
12 1,231 hugs
given |
#50
|
Reply With Quote |
missbella, Quietmind 2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#51
|
Reply With Quote |
BizzyBee, koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2
|
Member
Member Since Nov 2017
Location: Ohio
Posts: 63
6 83 hugs
given |
#52
According to this article there is going to be a 7th installment this week!
'The Shrink Next Door': New revelations about the Jewiest, screwiest podcast ever - Jewish Telegraphic Agency |
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi
|
underdog is here
Member Since Sep 2011
Location: blank
Posts: 34,722
(SuperPoster!)
12 1 hugs
given |
#53
I think this sort of thing happens more than anyone wants to admit, possibly on not as grand of a scale, and clients are too ashamed to tell anyone.
__________________ Please NO @ Selfishness is not living as one wishes to live, it is asking others to live as one wishes to live. Oscar Wilde Well Behaved Women Seldom Make History - Laurel Thatcher Ulrich Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional. |
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, missbella, Quietmind 2, Xynesthesia2
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Mar 2019
Location: USA
Posts: 540
5 55 hugs
given |
#54
I very much agree and, in fact, know a few cases via my work. Sometimes I actually feel that a really professionally managed, ethical provider-client relationship in the therapy field is is more scarce than all those that mix and match and blur everything in between.
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, missbella
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#55
Quote:
My therapists didn't exploit me outside the consulting room, but had detrimental sway over my life. I "stood up to my parents" according to the therapist's recipe, which was disastrous and had no effect. I also left a stable job for an unstable one just so I could please the therapist by demonstrating how I was "changing." Wondery - Feel The Story >> The Shrink Next Door The "Update" episode has a grab bag of topics. Discussion of psychiatric abuse and then an interview with Wolhberg begins about 22:36. The Update also mentions two important developments. After episode 6 Marty finally was interviewed by a lawyer from the New York Department of Health. Then in the last few days the psychiatrist resigned from his faculty position at NYU. |
|
Reply With Quote |
BizzyBee, koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#56
Two new articles have emerged around The Shrink Next Door, a new one...
'The Shrink Next Door': New revelations about the Jewiest, screwiest podcast ever - Jewish Telegraphic Agency ...and this one from 2006 which corroborates and important aspect of the podcast's assertions: Celebrity Crazy - The New York Times Though the psychiatrist isn't named, author Auslander does so in other writing. |
Reply With Quote |
Veteran Member
Member Since Oct 2011
Location: the sunny side of the street
Posts: 672
12 1,231 hugs
given |
#57
Quote:
yay! glad to hear that there have been some positive developments since the release of this podcast. |
|
Reply With Quote |
missbella
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Oct 2011
Location: the sunny side of the street
Posts: 672
12 1,231 hugs
given |
#58
Quote:
this was very validating for me to hear, but at the same a little unsettling too. |
|
Reply With Quote |
missbella
|
missbella, Quietmind 2
|
Grand Poohbah
Member Since Jun 2010
Location: here
Posts: 1,845
13 814 hugs
given |
#59
Quote:
Last edited by missbella; Jun 20, 2019 at 04:15 AM.. |
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, Quietmind 2
|
Veteran Member
Member Since Mar 2019
Location: USA
Posts: 540
5 55 hugs
given |
#60
The kinds of things the psychiatrist responds to the accusations in the 6th episode reminded me quite a bit of the sort of stuff my first T said defensively, when I criticized him. Also how Ike apparently said he resigned from NYU and the Ethics Board to save them from the adverse reactions. Once I told my T that I could report him for some of the things he said and did and his response was something like "I will no longer be able to protect you if you do that". It was a jaw-dropper for me, how can someone even come up with such twisted nonsense, to protect ME?! These people must really have psychopathic traits, no sense of remorse. One really needs to be born with a predisposition to these things as some of what they say and do would never even occur to most people, I think.
|
Reply With Quote |
koru_kiwi, missbella, Quietmind 2, stopdog
|