advertisement
Closed Thread
Thread Tools Display Modes
vonmoxie
deus ex machina
 
vonmoxie's Avatar
vonmoxie has no updates.
 
Member Since: Jul 2014
Location: Ticket-taking at the cartesian theater.
Posts: 2,379
8 yr Member
399 hugs
given
Default Sep 22, 2014 at 11:31 AM
  #1
I have complex PTSD, and had considered it to be comorbid with a couple of other things, including a current, follow-on episode of major depressive disorder which would be considered treatment-resistant based on the clinical definition or any other definition for that matter. I no longer consider this to be the case though.

I would suggest that there must be some portion of people whose "treatment-resistant depression" is actually representative of the depressive symptoms of PTSD/CPTSD, and would be better regarded as such. Myself among them.

From what I read last night in this most recent PC article, Brain Scan Study Aims to One Day Personalize PTSD Treatment, I am now thinking it is counter-productive, for me or anyone trying to treat me, to look at my depressive symptoms as being related to MDD or any other depressive disorder, when the better part of them are likely and rather the result of what is ultimately physical injury, but is termed psychiatric injury and is part and parcel of PTSD. Mainly I think it's counter-productive because of the nature of many psych professionals, in being so sure that the "right" anti-depressant or anti-depressant combination just has to be found, can result in a lot of lost time and in my case, a lot of lost hope where I had no sense of hope to begin with. Perhaps this belief on their part is understandable being that they have found it to be true in many cases of depression; but I've been aware for some time (and I've endured serious trauma since I was a young child) that anti-depressants simply do not work for me, based both on trial and error, and on my complete lack of response to them outside of a little tingling the first couple of times I try a new one.

I was struck by the article's description of kappa opioid receptors becoming retracted and largely inaccessible in PTSD, causing what is ultimately a physically induced dysphoria. While it's my belief that my earlier experiences with dysphoria, when I was a kid, may indeed have been related to major depressive episodes I'd had at the time, and they were overwhelming indeed, they were not so definite as the experience I'm having now. I feel shut down in a way that is very different now, and I haven't been able to quantify how that is but I've been overtly aware of it for some time. Perhaps at this point the number of receptors still exposed in my brain has lessened to an unfortunate tipping point. I don't know how they're going to coax them lil things back out of hiding, but I hope a solution is forthcoming soon, and is nothing too invasive. (sigh)

Quote:
“We know from previous clinical trials that antidepressants, for example, do not work well for dysphoria and the numbing symptoms often found in PTSD,” said Neumeister.

“Currently available antidepressants are just not linked specifically enough to the neurobiological basis of these symptoms in PTSD. Going forward, our study will help pave the way toward development of better options.”
I especially hope that in future psych professionals will become more motivated and adept at discerning when depressive symptoms are resulting from PTSD, so that anti-depressant therapy is not so frequently misapplied. I personally feel that with as little mental and spiritual energy as I've had these last couple of years, the time, effort, and focus on therapy that simply didn't work has actually made me worse. That is to say, to have such a disheartening experience when so low on heart to begin with can be quite stressful in itself, and may have sent even more of my receptors into hiding. My former practitioner clearly interpreted my insistence that it wasn't working for me as resistance, when in reality any resistance I may have ever had to anything has been all but entirely diminished for some time now.

My former practitioner was also of the opinion that we needed to "treat the depression first" before trying to deal with anything else; but if what is presenting as depression in a case like mine needs to be treated as PTSD, the folly of that thinking is fairly obvious. Wheels spinning ad infinitum.

While I wouldn't go so far as asserting that PTSD and depressive disorders could not be comorbid, I think what has been found in this study makes it clear that screening for PTSD up front is essential, and that treating depressive symptoms in the traditional manner when PTSD is present should be a more carefully considered option. Certainly not insisting on repeated rounds of anti-depressants, and having an attitude towards a patient that they must be resisting, or non-compliant, or drawing some other such unhelpful conclusion.

After all, riddle me this, in cases where a treatment is neither applicable nor indicated, how can its ineffectiveness then describe a condition as being treatment-resistant?

__________________
“We use our minds not to discover facts but to hide them. One of things the screen hides most effectively is the body, our own body, by which I mean, the ins and outs of it, its interiors. Like a veil thrown over the skin to secure its modesty, the screen partially removes from the mind the inner states of the body, those that constitute the flow of life as it wanders in the journey of each day.
Antonio R. Damasio, “The Feeling of What Happens: Body and Emotion in the Making of Consciousness” (p.28)

Last edited by vonmoxie; Sep 22, 2014 at 11:56 AM.. Reason: grammatical
vonmoxie is offline  
 
Hugs from:
embracinglife, Fuzzybear, katydid777, KYWoman, Lilly2
 
Thanks for this!
777palmtree, Alive99, HowDoYouFeelMeow?, KYWoman, Lilly2, LostOnTheTrail, Onward2wards, Otheraccountt17, Tardi, Werewoman

advertisement
Altered Moment
Elder
 
Altered Moment's Avatar
Altered Moment has no updates.
 
Member Since: Feb 2014
Location: Michigan
Posts: 5,481
10 yr Member PC PoohBah!
Default Sep 23, 2014 at 12:42 PM
  #2
Quote:
After all, riddle me this, in cases where a treatment is neither applicable nor indicated, how can its ineffectiveness then describe a condition as being treatment-resistant?
I don't think it should be, but as you already know I do not like the definition of two anti depressants not working. I am in total agreement with DocJohns definition-

Quote:
To me, and in this context, it means you've tried multiple treatment options -- whether it be psychotherapy, meds, ECT, TMS, whatever -- over a period of years and despite your (and your professionals') best efforts and multiple tries on different treatments (whether it be with different therapists, therapies, meds, etc.), very little has touched your depression. You are still depressed. It doesn't seem to have responded much to anything.

That's my definition. I'm going to close this thread to encourage you all to start new threads here on the topics of the most interest to you...
I do not have PTSD but I view it as depression is a symptom of PTSD along with other possible symptoms. A person might have PTSD and not have depression as a symptom and may have other symptoms. I agree with you that it is the PTSD that should be gone after. Maybe they are comorbid and should be treated at the same time but the primary focus should be the PTSD. My two cents anyway.

I googled "treatment resistant PTSD" to see what came up.

Treatment-resistant posttraumatic stress disorder... [CNS Spectr. 2004] - PubMed - NCBI Couldn't seem to find a link to the full article.
Quote:
Abstract
The mainstay of treatment for chronic posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a combination of psychotherapy and medication treatments. The first-line medications for PTSD are antidepressants, with two selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (sertraline and paroxetine) currently Food and Drug Administration-indicated for PTSD. However, many patients do not have an adequate response to antidepressants, therefore, combinations with other antidepressants or with other classes of psychotropic medication are often utilized to enhance the therapeutic response. Other agents that have been used include mood stabilizers, anti-adrenergics, anxiolytics, and atypical antipsychotics. The heterogeneity of symptom clusters in PTSD as well as the complex psychiatric comorbidities (eg, with depression or substance abuse) further support the notion that combinations of medications may be needed. To date, there is a paucity of data to support specific strategies for augmenting antidepressants in PTSD. This review will address representative existing studies and discuss several potential pharmacologic strategies for patients suffering from treatment-refractory PTSD.
It seems MDMA (ecstasy) holds some promise.
I'm a veteran who overcame treatment-resistant PTSD after participating in a clinical study of MDMA-assisted psychotherapy. My name is Tony Macie? Ask me anything! : IAmA

MDMA Cures Treatment-Resistant PTSD « Reset.me

I seem to remember hearing on the news that the US Military and VA has come up with some novel psychotherapy methods of treatment. Not sure how successful.

__________________
The "paradox" is only a conflict between reality and your feeling of what reality "ought to be." -- Richard Feynman

Major Depressive Disorder
Anxiety Disorder with some paranoid delusions thrown in for fun.
Recovering Alcoholic and Addict
Possibly on low end of bi polar spectrum...trying to decide.

Male, 50

Fetzima 80mg
Lamictal 100mg
Remeron 30mg for sleep
Klonopin .5mg twice a day, cutting this back
Altered Moment is offline  
 
Hugs from:
katydid777
 
Thanks for this!
boomerango
Tardi
New Member
Tardi has no updates.
 
Member Since: Dec 2017
Location: France
Posts: 1
5 yr Member
Default Dec 08, 2017 at 06:00 PM
  #3
You are right !
Tardi is offline  
 
Hugs from:
katydid777
Fuzzybear
Wisest Elder Ever
 
Fuzzybear's Avatar
Fuzzybear has no updates.
 
Member Since: Nov 2002
Location: Cave.
Posts: 96,300 (SuperPoster!)
20 yr Member
81.2k hugs
given
PC PoohBah!
Default Feb 19, 2018 at 05:11 PM
  #4

__________________
Fuzzybear is offline  
 
Hugs from:
katydid777, Lilly2
KYWoman
Member
 
KYWoman's Avatar
KYWoman is sinking
 
Member Since: Dec 2017
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 229
5 yr Member
1,218 hugs
given
Default Feb 20, 2018 at 03:57 PM
  #5
[QUOTE=vonmoxie;4011206]I have complex PTSD, and had considered it to be comorbid with a couple of other things, including a current, follow-on episode of major depressive disorder which would be considered treatment-resistant based on the clinical definition or any other definition for that matter. I no longer consider this to be the case though.

I would suggest that there must be some portion of people whose "treatment-resistant depression" is actually representative of the depressive symptoms of PTSD/CPTSD, and would be better regarded as such. Myself among them.

Your post has been very enlightening to me and I thank you. I've been treated for depression for decades: in and out of therapy, off and on medications. None of which have seemed very affective. Was diagnosed with PTSD 10 years ago. Only when I discovered this site 3 months ago and started perusing the many forums did I learn of complex PTSD. In hindsight, I probably should've been diagnosed decades ago with PTSD vs depression....but many too many secrets I didn't want to share because I had successfully buried them deep in a closet in my brain.

Genetic testing 4 to 5 years ago proved a missing gene had significant to moderate impact on most Rx drugs prescribed to me. Extremely validating for a moment! I know my body better than anyone and when I reported no improvement, I was considered "resistant". WTH? I WANT to feel better and if it's not working, it's just not working. Not everyone is tolerant of Rx drugs, sad to say. Big PHARMA is all about the money....not wellness.

Thanks for sharing and to you other members, thanks for adding to this thread!
KYWoman is offline  
 
Hugs from:
katydid777, Wild Coyote
 
Thanks for this!
Wild Coyote
Wild Coyote
Legendary
Community Liaison
 
Wild Coyote's Avatar
Wild Coyote has no updates.
 
Member Since: Jun 2016
Location: USA
Posts: 12,735 (SuperPoster!)
5 yr Member
70.9k hugs
given
PC PoohBah!
Heart Feb 20, 2018 at 04:53 PM
  #6
I wish much more was known about depression, PTSD/CPTSD and more mental health conditions.

I am all for trying meds to see if they do help.
I feel it's likely PTSD/CPTSD and depression co-exist in most cases.

Thanks for an interesting discussion.


WC

__________________
May we each fully claim the courage to live from our hearts, to allow Love, Faith and Hope to enLighten our paths.

Last edited by Wild Coyote; Feb 20, 2018 at 05:18 PM..
Wild Coyote is offline  
 
Hugs from:
Fuzzybear, katydid777, KYWoman
 
Thanks for this!
KYWoman
tecomsin
Magnate
tecomsin has no updates.
 
Member Since: Oct 2017
Location: canada
Posts: 2,007
5 yr Member
736 hugs
given
PC PoohBah!
Default Feb 20, 2018 at 05:50 PM
  #7
my gut feeling is that there are different types of depression that are all lumped together under the same word. That is misleading.

__________________
BP 1 with psychotic features
50 mg Lyrica
50 mcg Synthroid
2.5 mg olanzapine
tecomsin is offline  
 
Hugs from:
katydid777, KYWoman
 
Thanks for this!
Alive99, Fuzzybear, KYWoman
KYWoman
Member
 
KYWoman's Avatar
KYWoman is sinking
 
Member Since: Dec 2017
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 229
5 yr Member
1,218 hugs
given
Default Feb 22, 2018 at 06:30 PM
  #8
Anyone tried TMS therapy? Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation. Read it on a new member's post this afternoon. Quick research I did looked promising. I'd be more willing to try this vs ECT. I've recently learned a lot about magnetic stimulation and quantum mechanics so this is appealing to me for a lot of reasons I can't explain.
KYWoman is offline  
 
Hugs from:
katydid777
777palmtree
Junior Member
777palmtree Unable to function
 
Member Since: Aug 2016
Location: NorthEast
Posts: 11
5 yr Member
16 hugs
given
Post Feb 28, 2018 at 09:59 AM
  #9
Hi-

Thanks for the article. I have C-PTSD, and MDD. None of the meds have ever worked. Countless hours of therapy have brought me to the point in knowing I have childhood trauma....T states “mother yourself...treat yourself as you wanted to be treated as a child”. This is frustrating as I do not have to tools to do this. So I avoid going to T. I do isolate myself & I guess numbness is a good description. I basically exist.

I wish I could wave a magic wand and everyone’s pain would go away.

__________________
777palmtree

Diagnoses-major depressive disorder, complex PTSD, GAD
777palmtree is offline  
 
Hugs from:
KYWoman
 
Thanks for this!
KYWoman
Carmina
Poohbah
 
Carmina's Avatar
Carmina has no updates.
 
Member Since: Sep 2017
Location: A Growlery in the UK
Posts: 1,158
5 yr Member
129 hugs
given
Default Feb 28, 2018 at 11:57 AM
  #10
Quote:
Originally Posted by tecomsin View Post
my gut feeling is that there are different types of depression that are all lumped together under the same word. That is misleading.
Personally I think it helps to see depression as a symptom, one that can occur for many different reasons, rather than a particular clinical condition in itself. Same as pain is - there may be many causes and conditions that lead to the same symptom, but they all respond to treatment differently even if they have that one symptom in common.
Carmina is offline  
 
Thanks for this!
KYWoman, Otheraccountt17
dossman71
New Member
dossman71 has no updates.
 
Member Since: Apr 2018
Location: las vegas nv
Posts: 5
5 yr Member
Default May 01, 2018 at 05:59 PM
  #11
Yes-
Kentucky women. I tried this at the Las Vegas VA in December of last year. Put the coil on my head and tapped away for 27 sessions.I didn't feel any better after.but take into consideration my clinical depression is terribly treatment-resistant. So everybody will have different results. Steve
dossman71 is offline  
 
Thanks for this!
KYWoman
sming
Member
 
sming's Avatar
sming has no updates.
 
Member Since: Mar 2012
Posts: 29
10 yr Member
Default Feb 01, 2019 at 10:05 PM
  #12
Quote:
Originally Posted by dossman71 View Post
Yes-
Kentucky women. I tried this at the Las Vegas VA in December of last year. Put the coil on my head and tapped away for 27 sessions.I didn't feel any better after.but take into consideration my clinical depression is terribly treatment-resistant. So everybody will have different results. Steve


Ditto. 42 dTMS sessions.
sming is offline  
HowDoYouFeelMeow?
Grand Member
 
HowDoYouFeelMeow?'s Avatar
HowDoYouFeelMeow? has no updates.
 
Member Since: Sep 2014
Location: USA
Posts: 750
8 yr Member
893 hugs
given
PC PoohBah!
Default Feb 01, 2019 at 11:07 PM
  #13
Despite years of trying half a dozen SSRIs, SNRIs, etc. with no success, I once had a resident psychiatrist say I must take a serotonergic drug because his textbook said serotonin was related to mood. Fool. I gave him another chance, but he continued to be highly incompetent so I fired him.

__________________
"I think I'm a hypochondriac. I sure hope so, otherwise I'm just about to die."

PTSD
OCD
Anxiety
Major Depressive Disorder (Severe & Recurrent)
HowDoYouFeelMeow? is offline  
Werewoman
Poohbah
 
Werewoman's Avatar
Werewoman Is a bit, well...wered.
 
Member Since: May 2014
Location: Betelgeuse
Posts: 1,472
8 yr Member
1,217 hugs
given
PC PoohBah!
Default Oct 29, 2019 at 04:19 AM
  #14
I have both CPTSD and TRD. I take three different antidepressants and I can't say I'm much better off. My pdoc has asked me to try Spravato or ketamine treatments. Once I start the treatment, I will start a thread letting ppl know how it's going in case anyone else is interested in trying it.

__________________



You're only given one little spark of madness. You mustn't lose it. ~ Robin Williams

Did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage? ~ Pink Floyd
Werewoman is offline  
just2b
Veteran Member
just2b deleted
 
Member Since: Nov 2009
Location: SpACE
Posts: 597
10 yr Member
141 hugs
given
Default Jan 07, 2021 at 09:35 PM
  #15
When i was younger and put on meds, I was resistant but could not voice that its not a chemical imbalance but i have been abused. I have not had depression symptoms for years now, until recent. As a matter of like 2 weeks or so, not sure what has brought it on, just know that I have a lot of PTSD memories surface and a bad case of insomnia. I feel apathetic, disconnected, and yesterday and today, a few fleeting thoughts of suicide. Urges to self harm. I know its not chemical its years of repressing my traumas. Been working with a therapist for 7 years, and my dissociation makes for any real progress difficult. DID sucks. I know I may start on a pill but it wont last after a while I know parts of me will not take it and make sure of it. I am so confused on how I am feeling lately.
just2b is offline  
 
Hugs from:
Werewoman
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:40 PM.
Powered by vBulletin® — Copyright © 2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.



 

My Support Forums

My Support Forums is the online community that was originally begun as the Psych Central Forums in 2001. It now runs as an independent self-help support group community for mental health, personality, and psychological issues and is overseen by a group of dedicated, caring volunteers from around the world.

 

Helplines and Lifelines

The material on this site is for informational purposes only, and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis or treatment provided by a qualified health care provider.

Always consult your doctor or mental health professional before trying anything you read here.